Record e385506d4eed4fc2afe354f63594abbc
PASSVerdict and provenance first; raw prompt/response/reasoning below, collapsed.
✓PASSanswered "]"
Prompt
You are an operations planner. Below is the current state of a small deployment environment, a goal, and a catalog of tools you may call. Each tool has typed parameters and PRECONDITIONS that must hold at the moment you call it; calling a tool whose preconditions are not met is an error and your plan fails.
CURRENT STATE:
- billing-1 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- At the end of last week, scheduler-2 was fully torn down and has not been touched since.
- The release-image artifact does not exist yet.
- The db-migration artifact does not exist yet.
- No one has built the config-bundle artifact this cycle.
- reporting-0 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- The maintenance_window_open flag is off.
- The feature_gate_on flag is off.
- The secrets_synced flag is off.
GOAL (all conditions must hold at the end):
- service 'reporting-0' must reach at least the 'deployed' state
- service 'billing-1' must reach at least the 'configured' state
ENTITY IDS (use these exact ids in your tool args):
Services: svc_0 (reporting-0), svc_1 (billing-1), svc_2 (scheduler-2)
Artifacts: art_0 (release-image), art_1 (db-migration), art_2 (config-bundle)
Flags: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), flag_1 (secrets_synced), flag_2 (feature_gate_on), flag_interleave_3 (interleave_window)
TOOL CATALOG:
- id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the flag_0 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false.
- id: publish_art_0 | name: publish_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Publish the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'built' to 'published'). Precondition: the artifact must be 'built'.
- id: build_art_0 | name: build_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Build the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'absent' to 'built'). Precondition: the artifact must be 'absent'.
- id: decoy_0 | name: confirm_service_target | params: service: service
Confirms reporting-0 is tracking toward the required goal state.
- id: advance_0 | name: provision | params: service: service
Provision a service, moving it from 'down' to 'provisioned'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'down'.
- id: set_flag_1 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the flag_1 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the flag_0 flag first.
- id: advance_2 | name: deploy | params: service: service
Deploy a service, moving it from 'configured' to 'deployed'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'configured'. Requires the flag_1 flag to be set. Requires the art_0 artifact to be published. Requires the flag_interleave_3 window flag to be open.
- id: advance_1 | name: configure | params: service: service
Configure a service, moving it from 'provisioned' to 'configured'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'provisioned'. Requires the flag_interleave_3 window flag to be open.
- id: open_interleave_window | name: open_interleave_window | params: (no args)
Open the shared interleave window flag. Precondition: the flag must currently be closed.
Output ONLY a JSON array of tool calls that, executed in order from the current state, satisfies the goal. Each element must be an object {"tool": "<tool id>", "args": {"<param>": "<entity id>", ...}}. Do not include any prose, explanation, or markdown fences -- just the JSON array.
You may use at most 20 tool calls.
Response
[
{"tool":"set_flag_0","args":{"flag":"flag_0"}},
{"tool":"set_flag_1","args":{"flag":"flag_1"}},
{"tool":"open_interleave_window","args":{}},
{"tool":"build_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},
{"tool":"publish_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_0","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_0","args":{"service":"svc_1"}},
{"tool":"advance_1","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_1","args":{"service":"svc_1"}},
{"tool":"advance_2","args":{"service":"svc_0"}}
]
Reasoning
Model reasoning
We need to produce a JSON array of tool calls that will achieve the goal: reporting-0 must reach at least 'deployed' state, billing-1 must reach at least 'configured' state.
Current state summary:
- billing-1 is down (not yet provisioned). So its state is down? It says "currently down (not yet provisioned)". So its state is down.
- scheduler-2 was fully torn down and not touched since. So its state? Probably down as well, but not relevant.
- release-image artifact does not exist yet. So artifact is absent.
- db-migration artifact does not exist yet. Not relevant.
- No one has built the config-bundle artifact this cycle. So config-bundle artifact is absent.
- reporting-0 is currently down (not yet provisioned). So its state is down.
- maintenance_window_open flag is off (false).
- feature_gate_on flag is off (false).
- secrets_synced flag is off (false).
Goal: reporting-0 must reach at least 'deployed' state. billing-1 must reach at least 'configured' state.
We have tool calls that can provision services, configure, deploy, etc. Also need to set flags, build/publish artifacts, open interleave window.
We need to produce a plan that satisfies preconditions.
Let's list needed steps.
Goal for reporting-0: deployed. To deploy a service, we need:
- set advance_0: provision service (svc_0) from down to provisioned. Precondition: service must be down. That's true for reporting-0.
- Then configure service (advance_1) from provisioned to configured. Precondition: service must be provisioned, and requires flag_interleave_3 window flag to be open.
- Then deploy service (advance_2) from configured to deployed. Precondition: service must be configured, requires flag_1 flag to be set, requires art_0 artifact to be published, requires flag_interleave_3 window flag to be open.
Thus to get reporting-0 to deployed, we need to:
1. Provision svc_0 (reporting-0) using advance_0.
2. Open interleave window (open_interleave_window) to allow configure and deploy steps.
3. Build and publish art_0 (release-image) artifact: need to build it (build_art_0) then publish (publish_art_0). Build precondition: artifact must be absent (true). Publish precondition: artifact must be built.
4. Set flag_1 (feature_gate_on) to true. But set_flag_1 precondition: it must currently be false, and requires flag_0 flag first. flag_0 is maintenance_window_open flag. So we need to set flag_0 first (set_flag_0). Then we can set_flag_1.
But note: set_flag_1 requires flag_0 flag first. Actually the description: "id: set_flag_1 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag Requires the flag_0 flag first." Means that to set flag_1, flag_0 must be set? Or that flag_0 must be set before? Probably precondition: flag_0 must be true? Actually set_flag_1 precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the flag_0 flag first. Means you must have set flag_0 earlier? Possibly you need to have set flag_0 to true before you can set flag_1. So we need to set_flag_0 (set maintenance_window_open to true) first, then set_flag_1 (set feature_gate_on to true). However set_flag_0 precondition: it must currently be false. So we can set it now.
Thus steps:
- set_flag_0 (set maintenance_window_open to true). Precondition: currently false, satisfied.
- Then set_flag_1 (set feature_gate_on to true). Precondition: currently false, and requires flag_0 flag first (i.e., flag_0 must be true). So after setting flag_0, we can set_flag_1.
Now we have flag_1 true.
Now we need to open interleave window (open_interleave_window). Precondition: flag must currently be closed. That's flag_interleave_3? Actually open_interleave_window tool has no args, just opens the shared interleave window flag. Precondition: the flag must currently be closed. So we can call it now.
Now we can configure svc_0 (advance_1) because it requires service provisioned and flag_interleave_3 open. So after provisioning, we can configure.
But also we need to deploy svc_0 (advance_2) which requires service configured, flag_1 true, art_0 published, and flag_interleave_3 open. So we need to have built and published art_0 before deploying.
Thus order:
1. set_flag_0 (set maintenance_window_open to true) - sets flag_0 true.
2. set_flag_1 (set feature_gate_on to true) - sets flag_1 true.
3. open_interleave_window - opens interleave window flag.
Now we can proceed with artifact building and service provisioning.
But note: The provision step (advance_0) does not depend on flags? It only requires service down. That's fine.
But we might need to build art_0 before publishing. So we need to build_art_0 (build release-image) then publish_art_0 (publish artifact). However we also need to ensure that we have built config-bundle? Not needed for goal? The goal only mentions reporting-0 deployed and billing-1 configured. But there may be dependencies: maybe config-bundle is needed for something else? Not mentioned. However there is a flag_interleave_3 window flag that must be open for configure and deploy. That's separate.
But we also need to configure billing-1 to reach at least configured state. To configure billing-1, we need to provision it first (advance_0 for svc_1). Then configure (advance_1) which requires service provisioned and flag_interleave_3 open. So after we open interleave window, we can configure billing-1.
Thus we need to provision billing-1 (svc_1) as well.
But we also need to ensure that after provisioning both services, we can configure billing-1 (maybe after provisioning). However we also need to deploy reporting-0 (svc_0) to deployed state. That requires flag_1 true, art_0 published, and interleave window open.
Thus we need to sequence steps to satisfy all preconditions.
Potential plan:
- set_flag_0 (set maintenance_window_open to true)
- set_flag_1 (set feature_gate_on to true) (requires flag_0 true)
- open_interleave_window (open interleave window flag)
Now we can proceed with artifact building and publishing.
- build_art_0 (build release-image) (artifact art_0 is absent, so can build)
- publish_art_0 (publish release-image) (artifact must be built, now built)
Now we can provision services:
- advance_0 (provision svc_0) (service reporting-0 is down, can provision)
- advance_0 (provision svc_1) (service billing-1 is down, can provision)
Now we can configure services (advance_1) because they are provisioned and interleave window is open.
- advance_1 (configure svc_0) (service reporting-0 is provisioned, interleave window open) -> moves to configured.
- advance_1 (configure svc_1) (service billing-1 is provisioned, interleave window open) -> moves to configured.
Now we can deploy reporting-0 (advance_2) because it is configured, flag_1 true, art_0 published, interleave window open.
- advance_2 (deploy svc_0) -> moves to deployed.
Now we have reporting-0 deployed, billing-1 configured. Goal satisfied.
We must ensure we do not exceed 20 tool calls. We have used: set_flag_0, set_flag_1, open_interleave_window, build_art_0, publish_art_0, advance_0 (svc_0), advance_0 (svc_1), advance_1 (svc_0), advance_1 (svc_1), advance_2 (svc_0). That's 10 calls.
Check preconditions for each:
- set_flag_0: precondition: flag_0 must be false. Initially it's off (false). So okay.
- set_flag_1: precondition: flag_1 must be false (currently false) and requires flag_0 flag first. After set_flag_0, flag_0 is true, so okay.
- open_interleave_window: precondition: flag must be closed. Initially it's closed (off). So okay.
- build_art_0: precondition: artifact must be absent. It is absent. So okay.
- publish_art_0: precondition: artifact must be built. After build_art_0, it's built. So okay.
- advance_0 (svc_0): precondition: service must be down. reporting-0 is down. So okay.
- advance_0 (svc_1): precondition: service must be down. billing-1 is down. So okay.
- advance_1 (svc_0): precondition: service must be provisioned. After advance_0, it's provisioned. Also requires flag_interleave_3 open. We opened it earlier, so okay.
- advance_1 (svc_1): same.
- advance_2 (svc_0): precondition: service must be configured. After advance_1, it's configured. Requires flag_1 flag to be set (true). Yes. Requires art_0 published (true). Yes. Requires flag_interleave_3 open (true). Yes.
Thus all good.
One nuance: The tool "advance_0" is provision, which moves from down to provisioned. It doesn't have any other preconditions. So fine.
Now we need to output JSON array of tool calls with exact ids and args.
Tool ids:
- set_flag_0 -> id: set_flag_0
- set_flag_1 -> id: set_flag_1
- open_interleave_window -> id: open_interleave_window (no args)
- build_art_0 -> id: build_art_0, args: {"artifact": "art_0"} (artifact id is art_0)
- publish_art_0 -> id: publish_art_0, args: {"artifact": "art_0"}
- advance_0 -> id: advance_0, args: {"service": "svc_0"} for reporting-0, and later {"service": "svc_1"} for billing-1.
- advance_1 -> id: advance_1, args: {"service": "svc_0"} and {"service": "svc_1"}
- advance_2 -> id: advance_2, args: {"service": "svc_0"}
Thus the JSON array should be in order of execution.
Let's list them:
1. {"tool":"set_flag_0","args":{}} (no args? The tool definition: set_flag_0 takes param flag: flag. Actually set_flag_0 name: set_flag | params: flag: flag. So we need to pass the flag identifier? The flag_0 is the flag name? The tool args likely require "flag": "flag_0"? Actually the tool description: "id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag". So the parameter is "flag" and expects the flag identifier? Probably we need to pass the flag id string, maybe "flag_0"? But the entity IDs list includes flag_0 (maintenance_window_open). The tool likely expects the flag identifier as a string, maybe "flag_0". However the instruction says "Use these exact ids in your tool args". The entity IDs are flag_0, flag_1, flag_2, flag_interleave_3. So when calling set_flag_0, we need to pass flag: "flag_0"? Or maybe just "flag_0"? The param name is "flag". So args: {"flag":"flag_0"}.
But the tool id is set_flag_0, which sets flag_0? Actually set_flag_0 is a specific tool that sets flag_0. So maybe no args needed? The param is flag: flag, but maybe they want the flag identifier as the value. Since the tool is named set_flag_0, maybe it implicitly sets flag_0, so no args needed. However the param list says "flag: flag". That suggests you need to provide the flag identifier. But the tool id already indicates which flag? Actually there are multiple set_flag tools? Only set_flag_0 is defined. So maybe it sets flag_0, and the param is just the flag identifier, which must be "flag_0". So we need to pass {"flag":"flag_0"}.
But the instruction: "Use these exact ids in your tool args". The entity IDs include flag_0. So we should use "flag_0" as the value for the flag parameter.
Thus for set_flag_0, args: {"flag":"flag_0"}.
Similarly, set_flag_1 sets flag_1, so args: {"flag":"flag_1"}.
open_interleave_window has no args.
build_art_0 takes artifact: artifact, so args: {"artifact":"art_0"}.
publish_art_0 same.
advance_0 takes service: service, so args: {"service":"svc_0"} etc.
advance_1 same.
advance_2 same.
Thus we need to include these args.
Now produce JSON array.
Sequence:
1. set_flag_0 with flag:"flag_0"
2. set_flag_1 with flag:"flag_1"
3. open_interleave_window (no args)
4. build_art_0 with artifact:"art_0"
5. publish_art_0 with artifact:"art_0"
6. advance_0 with service:"svc_0"
7. advance_0 with service:"svc_1"
8. advance_1 with service:"svc_0"
9. advance_1 with service:"svc_1"
10. advance_2 with service:"svc_0"
Check if any step requires flag_interleave_3 open before configure steps. We opened it at step 3, so okay.
Now ensure that we didn't need to set flag_interleave_3 explicitly? There's a flag_interleave_3 flag that must be open for configure and deploy. The tool open_interleave_window opens the shared interleave window flag. So we used that.
Now final JSON array.
Make sure it's a JSON array of objects, each with "tool" and "args". No extra text.
Thus output:
[
{"tool":"set_flag_0","args":{"flag":"flag_0"}},
{"tool":"set_flag_1","args":{"flag":"flag_1"}},
{"tool":"open_interleave_window","args":{}},
{"tool":"build_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},
{"tool":"publish_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_0","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_0","args":{"service":"svc_1"}},
{"tool":"advance_1","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_1","args":{"service":"svc_1"}},
{"tool":"advance_2","args":{"service":"svc_0"}}
]
Check that we didn't exceed 20 calls: 10 calls, fine.
Now ensure that the JSON is valid: keys need to be quoted, strings quoted. The args objects have keys quoted.
Thus final answer is just that JSON array.
Realized dims
| dim | value |
|---|---|
| catalog_size | 9.0 |
| chain_length | 4.0 |
| decoy_count | 1.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 1.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 0.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 0.0 |
| irreversibility | 0.0 |
| parallel_goals | 2.0 |
| plan_overhead | 0.0 |
| poison_traps | 0.0 |
| realized_plan_depth | 10.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.2222222222222222 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |
Latent params
| param | value |
|---|---|
| decoy_tools | 1.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 1.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 0.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 0.0 |
| irreversibility | 0.0 |
| parallel_goals | 2.0 |
| plan_depth | 3.0 |
| poison_traps | 0.0 |
| precondition_chain | 2.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.16880741836624066 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |