Record 67cd7d8c052e406b99b41fd2a33dd2ff
PASSVerdict and provenance first; raw prompt/response/reasoning below, collapsed.
✓PASSanswered "]"
Prompt
You are an operations planner. Below is the current state of a small deployment environment, a goal, and a catalog of tools you may call. Each tool has typed parameters and PRECONDITIONS that must hold at the moment you call it; calling a tool whose preconditions are not met is an error and your plan fails.
ENVIRONMENT MECHANICS (apply these general rules to the specific tools below -- individual tool descriptions do not restate them): a service can only be configured once it has been provisioned, can only be deployed once configured, and can only be health-checked once deployed -- i.e. each rung of the down -> provisioned -> configured -> deployed -> healthy ladder requires the previous rung. An artifact can only be published once it has been built. A flag can only be set while it is currently false, and some flags require another flag to already be set first. Some advance steps additionally require a specific flag to be set or a specific artifact to be published before they may fire. Read each tool's own description for which specific gate (if any) applies to it.
CURRENT STATE:
- billing-0 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- auth-api-2 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- The release-image artifact does not exist yet.
- The db-migration artifact does not exist yet.
- The maintenance_window_open flag is off.
- reporting-1 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- The secrets_synced flag was never enabled after the last reset.
GOAL (all conditions must hold at the end):
- service 'billing-0' must reach at least the 'healthy' state
- service 'reporting-1' must reach at least the 'configured' state
ENTITY IDS (use these exact ids in your tool args):
Services: svc_0 (billing-0), svc_1 (reporting-1), svc_2 (auth-api-2)
Artifacts: art_0 (release-image), art_1 (db-migration)
Flags: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), flag_1 (secrets_synced), flag_interleave_2 (interleave_window)
TOOL CATALOG:
- id: build_art_0 | name: build_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Build the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'absent' to 'built').
- id: poiso_n_trap | name: sync_release_state | params: service: service
Reconcile billing-0's deployment metadata ahead of rollout.
- id: publish_art_o0 | name: publish_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Publish the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'built' to 'published').
- id: set_flag_o0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the flag_0 flag to true.
- id: decoy_o1 | name: warm_cache | params: service: service
Warm the cache for a service (best-effort, no state change). (Has no effect on deployment state.)
- id: decoy_o2 | name: ping_healthcheck | params: service: service
Ping a service's healthcheck endpoint (diagnostic only). (Has no effect on deployment state.)
- id: advance_o2 | name: deploy | params: service: service
Deploy a service, moving it from 'configured' to 'deployed'.
- id: advance_o0 | name: provision | params: service: service
Provision a service, moving it from 'down' to 'provisioned'.
- id: decoy_o0 | name: audit_logs | params: service: service
Audit the log stream for a service (read-only). (Has no effect on deployment state.)
- id: adva-nce_3 | name: health-check | params: service: service
Health-check a service, moving it from 'deployed' to 'healthy'. Requires the flag_0 flag to be set. Requires the art_0 artifact to be published. Requires the flag_interleave_2 window flag to be open.
- id: adva_nce_1 | name: configure | params: service: service
Configure a service, moving it from 'provisioned' to 'configured'. Requires the flag_interleave_2 window flag to be open.
- id: open_interleave_window | name: open_interleave_window | params: (no args)
Open the shared interleave window flag.
Output ONLY a JSON array of tool calls that, executed in order from the current state, satisfies the goal. Each element must be an object {"tool": "<tool id>", "args": {"<param>": "<entity id>", ...}}. Do not include any prose, explanation, or markdown fences -- just the JSON array.
You may use at most 20 tool calls.
Response
[
{"tool": "build_art_0", "args": {"artifact": "art_0"}},
{"tool": "publish_art_o0", "args": {"artifact": "art_0"}},
{"tool": "open_interleave_window", "args": {}},
{"tool": "set_flag_o0", "args": {"flag": "flag_0"}},
{"tool": "advance_o0", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}},
{"tool": "advance_o0", "args": {"service": "svc_1"}},
{"tool": "adva_nce_1", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}},
{"tool": "adva_nce_1", "args": {"service": "svc_1"}},
{"tool": "advance_o2", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}},
{"tool": "adva-nce_3", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}}
]
Reasoning
Model reasoning
We need to produce a JSON array of tool calls that will achieve the goal: billing-0 must reach at least healthy state, reporting-1 must reach at least configured state.
Current state summary:
- billing-0 is down (not provisioned). So need provision -> configure -> deploy -> health-check to become healthy. Also health-check requires flag_0 (maintenance_window_open) set, art_0 published, flag_interleave_2 open.
- auth-api-2 is down (not provisioned). Not directly needed for goal, but may be used? Possibly not needed.
- release-image artifact does not exist yet. That's art_0.
- db-migration artifact does not exist yet. That's art_1.
- maintenance_window_open flag is off (flag_0). So need to set it true.
- reporting-1 is down (not provisioned). Need to provision it, then configure it (needs flag_interleave_2 open). It does not need health-check; only configured.
- secrets_synced flag was never enabled after the last reset. That's flag_1. Not sure if needed for anything; maybe not required.
- flag_interleave_2 (interleave_window) is not mentioned; likely off initially. Need to open it for configure and maybe other steps.
Goal: billing-0 healthy, reporting-1 configured.
Thus we need to:
1. Build artifact art_0 (release-image). Use build_art_0.
2. Publish artifact art_0 (publish_artifact). Use publish_artifact.
3. Open interleave window flag (open_interleave_window). This sets flag_interleave_2 to true.
4. Set maintenance_window_open flag (set_flag_0). Use set_flag with flag_0.
5. Provision billing-0 (svc_0). Use provision with service svc_0.
6. Configure billing-0 (configure). Use configure with service svc_0. This moves from provisioned to configured. But we need to go to healthy, which requires health-check after deploy. Actually steps: provision -> configure -> deploy -> health-check. So after provision, we need configure (requires flag_interleave_2 open, which we will have). Then deploy (advance_o2). Then health-check (adva-nce_3) which requires flag_0, art_0 published, flag_interleave_2 open.
Thus we need to:
- Provision svc_0.
- Configure svc_0.
- Deploy svc_0.
- Health-check svc_0.
But also need to ensure that the artifact art_0 is published before health-check; we will publish it earlier.
Now for reporting-1 (svc_1). Need to provision it, then configure it (needs flag_interleave_2 open). That's it; we don't need to deploy or health-check.
Thus steps:
- Provision svc_1.
- Configure svc_1.
Potentially also need to build and publish artifact art_1? Not required for goal; but maybe needed for some other steps? Not needed.
But note: some tools may have preconditions that require other flags or artifacts. Let's list all tools and their preconditions:
- build_art_0: no preconditions? It just builds artifact from absent to built. Probably can be called anytime.
- publish_artifact: requires artifact built (i.e., built). So must call build_art_0 first.
- set_flag_0: can only be set while currently false. So we can set it when false; after setting, cannot set again. No other precondition.
- open_interleave_window: no args; presumably can be called anytime; maybe can be called multiple times? Not specified; but likely can be called anytime; but maybe only needed once.
- configure (adva_nce_1): requires flag_interleave_2 open. So we need to open it before configuring any service that requires it. Both billing-0 and reporting-1 require configure? Actually configure is needed for both services to move from provisioned to configured. The description says "Configure a service, moving it from 'provisioned' to 'configured'. Requires the flag_interleave_2 window flag to be open." So both services need it.
- deploy (advance_o2): moves from configured to deployed. No explicit precondition besides being configured.
- health-check (adva-nce_3): requires flag_0 set, art_0 published, flag_interleave_2 open.
Thus we need to sequence calls respecting these.
Goal: at most 20 calls; we will use maybe ~12.
Let's outline plan:
1. build_art_0 artifact art_0.
2. publish_artifact artifact art_0.
3. open_interleave_window (no args). This sets flag_interleave_2 open.
4. set_flag_0 flag_0 (maintenance_window_open) to true.
Now we can proceed with provisioning and configuring services.
5. provision service svc_0 (billing-0). This moves from down to provisioned.
6. provision service svc_1 (reporting-1). Moves from down to provisioned.
Now configure both services (requires flag_interleave_2 open, which we have).
7. configure service svc_0.
8. configure service svc_1.
Now deploy billing-0 (since we need to get to deployed before health-check). Actually we need to deploy to move from configured to deployed.
9. deploy service svc_0.
Now health-check billing-0 (requires flag_0, art_0 published, flag_interleave_2 open). All satisfied.
10. health-check service svc_0.
Now reporting-1 only needs to be configured; we already configured it, so it's at configured state, which meets goal (at least configured). No need to deploy or health-check.
Thus we have 10 calls. But need to ensure ordering: configure before deploy; health-check after deploy; also need to ensure that configure for billing-0 occurs after provision and after flag_interleave_2 open (which we have). That's fine.
But note: health-check requires flag_0 set (maintenance_window_open). We set it earlier; okay.
Also health-check requires flag_interleave_2 open; we opened it earlier; okay.
Also health-check requires art_0 published; we published earlier; okay.
Thus sequence is valid.
But check preconditions for configure: requires flag_interleave_2 open. We opened it before any configure calls, so fine.
Now check that we cannot call configure on a service that is not provisioned; we have provisioned both services before configure, so okay.
Now check that we cannot call deploy on a service that is not configured; we have configured both services, so okay.
Now check that we cannot call health-check on a service that is not deployed; we will deploy before health-check, so okay.
Now check that we cannot call set_flag_0 after it's already true; we will set it once when false; after that it's true; we won't set again.
Now check that we cannot call open_interleave_window multiple times? Not restricted; but we will call it once.
Now check that we cannot call publish_artifact before building; we will build then publish.
Now check that we cannot call build_artifact before anything; it's fine.
Now check that we cannot call any tool that requires a flag to be false when it's already true; but we only set flag_0 once; after that it's true; we won't call set_flag_0 again.
Now check that we cannot call configure on a service that already is configured; we will call configure only once per service.
Now check that we cannot call provision on a service that is not down; we will provision only when down; after provision it becomes provisioned; we won't provision again.
Now check that we cannot call deploy on a service that is not configured; we will deploy after configure.
Now check that we cannot call health-check on a service that is not deployed; we will health-check after deploy.
Thus sequence is valid.
Now we need to output JSON array of tool calls with exact ids and args.
Tool ids:
- build_art_0
- publish_artifact (id: publish_art_o0? Wait catalog: "id: publish_art_o0 | name: publish_artifact". The id is "publish_art_o0". Actually the catalog shows:
- id: publish_art_o0 | name: publish_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Thus the tool id is "publish_art_o0". Not "publish_artifact". So we must use the id exactly as given.
Similarly, "id: set_flag_o0 | name: set_flag". So id is "set_flag_o0".
"open_interleave_window" id is "open_interleave_window" (no args). Actually catalog: "id: open_interleave_window | name: open_interleave_window | params: (no args)". So id is "open_interleave_window".
"advance_o2" id is "advance_o2" (deploy). Actually catalog: "id: advance_o2 | name: deploy". So id is "advance_o2".
"adva-nce_3" id is "adva-nce_3" (health-check). Actually catalog: "id: adva-nce_3 | name: health-check". So id is "adva-nce_3".
"adva_nce_1" id is "adva_nce_1" (configure). Actually catalog: "id: adva_nce_1 | name: configure". So id is "adva_nce_1".
"provision" id is "advance_o0"? Wait catalog: "id: advance_o0 | name: provision". So id is "advance_o0".
"configure" id is "adva_nce_1". Good.
Now we need to map entity ids:
- artifact: art_0 (release-image). So param "artifact": "art_0".
- service: svc_0 (billing-0), svc_1 (reporting-1), svc_2 (auth-api-2). Use exact ids.
- flag: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open). The flag id is "flag_0"? Actually catalog: "id: set_flag_o0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag". So param name is "flag". The flag id is "flag_0"? The description says "flag_0 (maintenance_window_open)". So we pass flag: "flag_0". Similarly, flag_interleave_2 is "flag_interleave_2". But we only need to open the window via open_interleave_window tool; no param needed.
Thus the tool calls:
1. {"tool": "build_art_0", "args": {"artifact": "art_0"}}
2. {"tool": "publish_art_o0", "args": {"artifact": "art_0"}}
3. {"tool": "open_interleave_window", "args": {}}
4. {"tool": "set_flag_o0", "args": {"flag": "flag_0"}}
5. {"tool": "advance_o0", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}} // provision billing-0
6. {"tool": "advance_o0", "args": {"service": "svc_1"}} // provision reporting-1
7. {"tool": "adva_nce_1", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}} // configure billing-0
8. {"tool": "adva_nce_1", "args": {"service": "svc_1"}} // configure reporting-1
9. {"tool": "advance_o2", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}} // deploy billing-0
10. {"tool": "adva-nce_3", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}} // health-check billing-0
Check that we used correct ids: "adva-nce_3" includes a hyphen; must match exactly. In JSON string, we need to escape hyphen? No, it's just a string. So "adva-nce_3". Ensure correct spelling: catalog shows "adva-nce_3". Yes.
Now check that we didn't need to configure auth-api-2; not needed.
Now ensure that we didn't exceed 20 calls; we have 10.
Now ensure that each tool call's precondition is satisfied at that point.
Let's simulate:
Initial state:
- artifact art_0 absent.
- artifact art_1 absent (not needed).
- flag_0 off.
- flag_interleave_2 off.
- services down.
- secrets_synced never enabled (flag_1 off) but not used.
Now call 1: build_art_0 artifact art_0. Precondition: artifact absent; fine. Moves to built.
Call 2: publish_art_o0 artifact art_0. Precondition: artifact built; fine. Moves to published.
Call 3: open_interleave_window. No precondition; fine. Sets flag_interleave_2 open.
Call 4: set_flag_o0 flag flag_0. Precondition: flag currently false; it's off; fine. Sets to true.
Now flag_0 true, flag_interleave_2 true.
Call 5: advance_o0 service svc_0 (provision). Precondition: service down; svc_0 is down; fine. Moves to provisioned.
Call 6: advance_o0 service svc_1 (provision). Precondition: service down; fine. Moves to provisioned.
Now both services provisioned.
Call 7: adva_nce_1 service svc_0 (configure). Precondition: service provisioned; yes. Also requires flag_interleave_2 open; yes. So configure moves to configured.
Call 8: adva_nce_1 service svc_1 (configure). Same; moves to configured.
Now both services configured.
Call 9: advance_o2 service svc_0 (deploy). Precondition: service configured; yes. Moves to deployed.
Call 10: adva-nce_3 service svc_0 (health-check). Preconditions: flag_0 set (true), art_0 published (true), flag_interleave_2 open (true). All satisfied. Moves to healthy.
Now goal satisfied: billing-0 healthy, reporting-1 configured.
Thus sequence works.
Now ensure that we didn't need to configure reporting-1 further; it's configured, goal met.
Now output JSON array of these 10 objects.
Make sure to use exact tool ids:
- build_art_0
- publish_art_o0
- open_interleave_window
- set_flag_o0
- advance_o0
- adva_nce_1
- advance_o2
- adva-nce_3
Check that we used "adva_nce_1" for configure; correct.
Now ensure that we used "advance_o2" for deploy; correct.
Now ensure that we used "adva-nce_3" for health-check; correct.
Now ensure that we used "set_flag_o0" with param flag: "flag_0". Yes.
Now ensure that we used "open_interleave_window" with no args; args empty object {}.
Now ensure that we used "publish_art_o0" with param artifact: "art_0". Yes.
Now ensure that we used "build_art_0" with param artifact: "art_0". Yes.
Now ensure that we used "advance_o0" for provisioning both services; correct.
Now produce JSON array.
Potential nuance: The tool id for health-check is "adva-nce_3". It includes a hyphen; must be exactly as given. In JSON, it's fine.
Now produce final answer: just JSON array, no extra text.
Let's write it:
[
{"tool": "build_art_0", "args": {"artifact": "art_0"}},
{"tool": "publish_art_o0", "args": {"artifact": "art_0"}},
{"tool": "open_interleave_window", "args": {}},
{"tool": "set_flag_o0", "args": {"flag": "flag_0"}},
{"tool": "advance_o0", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}},
{"tool": "advance_o0", "args": {"service": "svc_1"}},
{"tool": "adva_nce_1", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}},
{"tool": "adva_nce_1", "args": {"service": "svc_1"}},
{"tool": "advance_o2", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}},
{"tool": "adva-nce_3", "args": {"service": "svc_0"}}
]
Check that we didn't include any extra commas or trailing commas. Ensure proper JSON.
Now output exactly that.
Realized dims
| dim | value |
|---|---|
| catalog_size | 12.0 |
| chain_length | 3.0 |
| decoy_count | 3.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 0.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 1.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 1.0 |
| irreversibility | 1.0 |
| parallel_goals | 2.0 |
| plan_overhead | 0.0 |
| poison_traps | 1.0 |
| realized_plan_depth | 10.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.14285714285714285 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |
Latent params
| param | value |
|---|---|
| decoy_tools | 3.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 0.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 1.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 1.0 |
| irreversibility | 0.0 |
| parallel_goals | 2.0 |
| plan_depth | 4.0 |
| poison_traps | 1.0 |
| precondition_chain | 1.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.2 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |