Record 208d23e3cf664cfea262841848124a84
PASSVerdict and provenance first; raw prompt/response/reasoning below, collapsed.
✓PASSanswered "]"
Prompt
You are an operations planner. Below is the current state of a small deployment environment, a goal, and a catalog of tools you may call. Each tool has typed parameters and PRECONDITIONS that must hold at the moment you call it; calling a tool whose preconditions are not met is an error and your plan fails.
CURRENT STATE:
- billing-0 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- cache-1 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- The release-image artifact does not exist yet.
- The db-migration artifact does not exist yet.
- The maintenance_window_open flag is off.
- The secrets_synced flag is off.
- The feature_gate_on flag is off.
- The backup_taken flag is off.
- The quota_raised flag is off.
- The maintenance_window_open flag is off.
- The secrets_synced flag is off.
GOAL (all conditions must hold at the end):
- service 'billing-0' must reach at least the 'healthy' state
ENTITY IDS (use these exact ids in your tool args):
Services: svc_0 (billing-0), svc_1 (cache-1)
Artifacts: art_0 (release-image), art_1 (db-migration)
Flags: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), flag_1 (secrets_synced), depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on), depth_flag_1 (backup_taken), depth_flag_2 (quota_raised), depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open), depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced)
TOOL CATALOG:
- id: build_art_0 | name: build_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Build the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'absent' to 'built'). Precondition: the artifact must be 'absent'.
- id: advance_2 | name: deploy | params: service: service
Deploy a service, moving it from 'configured' to 'deployed'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'configured'.
- id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the flag_0 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false.
- id: publish_art_0 | name: publish_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Publish the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'built' to 'published'). Precondition: the artifact must be 'built'.
- id: advance_0 | name: provision | params: service: service
Provision a service, moving it from 'down' to 'provisioned'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'down'.
- id: set_depth_flag_3 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_3 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_2 flag first.
- id: decoy_0 | name: audit_logs | params: service: service
Audit the log stream for a service (read-only). (Has no effect on deployment state.)
- id: set_depth_flag_1 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_1 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_0 flag first.
- id: advance_3 | name: health-check | params: service: service
Health-check a service, moving it from 'deployed' to 'healthy'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'deployed'. Requires the depth_flag_4 flag to be set. Requires the art_0 artifact to be published.
- id: set_depth_flag_2 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_2 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_1 flag first.
- id: set_depth_flag_4 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_4 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_3 flag first.
- id: decoy_1 | name: warm_cache | params: service: service
Warm the cache for a service (best-effort, no state change). (Has no effect on deployment state.)
- id: advance_1 | name: configure | params: service: service
Configure a service, moving it from 'provisioned' to 'configured'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'provisioned'.
- id: set_depth_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_0 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the flag_0 flag first.
Output ONLY a JSON array of tool calls that, executed in order from the current state, satisfies the goal. Each element must be an object {"tool": "<tool id>", "args": {"<param>": "<entity id>", ...}}. Do not include any prose, explanation, or markdown fences -- just the JSON array.
You may use at most 24 tool calls.
Response
[
{"tool":"set_flag_0","args":{"flag":"flag_0"}},
{"tool":"set_depth_flag_0","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_0"}},
{"tool":"set_depth_flag_1","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_1"}},
{"tool":"set_depth_flag_2","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_2"}},
{"tool":"set_depth_flag_3","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_3"}},
{"tool":"set_depth_flag_4","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_4"}},
{"tool":"build_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},
{"tool":"publish_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_0","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_1","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_2","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},
{"tool":"advance_3","args":{"service":"svc_0"}}
]
Reasoning
Model reasoning
We need to produce a sequence of tool calls leading to billing-0 healthy.
Goal: service billing-0 (svc_0) must be at least healthy.
Current state:
- billing-0 is down (not yet provisioned). So we need to go through states: down -> provisioned -> configured -> deployed -> healthy.
Provision uses advance_0 (provision): moves from down to provisioned. Precondition: service must be down.
Configure uses advance_1 (configure): moves from provisioned to configured. Precondition: service must be provisioned.
Deploy uses advance_2 (deploy): moves from configured to deployed. Precondition: service must be configured.
Health-check uses advance_3 (health-check): moves from deployed to healthy. Precondition: service must be deployed AND requires depth_flag_4 flag to be set AND requires art_0 artifact to be published.
Thus before health-check we need depth_flag_4 true and art_0 published.
Now let's see flags hierarchy:
depth_flag_0 depends on flag_0 (maintenance_window_open). Actually description: set_depth_flag_0 sets depth_flag_0 true, precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the flag_0 flag first. Means flag_0 must be true? It says "Requires the flag_0 flag first." Likely means flag_0 must already be true before setting depth_flag_0.
Similarly set_depth_flag_1 requires depth_flag_0 first.
set_depth_flag_2 requires depth_flag_1 first.
set_depth_flag_3 requires depth_flag_2 first.
set_depth_flag_4 requires depth_flag_3 first.
So chain: flag_0 -> depth_flag_0 -> depth_flag_1 -> depth_flag_2 -> depth_flag_3 -> depth_flag_4.
Also there are other flags: flag_1 (secrets_synced) maybe independent but not needed.
flag_0 initially off. We can set flag_0 using set_flag_0 (id: set_flag_0). That sets flag_0 true. Precondition: it must currently be false.
Then after flag_0 true, we can set depth_flag_0 via set_depth_flag_0.
After depth_flag_0 true, set depth_flag_1 via set_depth_flag_1.
After depth_flag_1 true, set depth_flag_2 via set_depth_flag_2.
After depth_flag_2 true, set depth_flag_3 via set_depth_flag_3.
After depth_flag_3 true, set depth_flag_4 via set_depth_flag_4.
Now also need art_0 published.
Artifact flow: start absent. Need to build then publish.
build_art_0 builds art_0 (absent->built). Precondition: artifact absent.
publish_art_0 publishes art_0 (built->published). Precondition: artifact built.
Thus steps: build_art_0 then publish_art_0.
Now ensure ordering constraints: For health-check we need both depth_flag_4 true and art_0 published. Also service must be deployed.
Thus overall plan:
1. set_flag_0 (to turn on maintenance_window_open)
2. set_depth_flag_0
3. set_depth_flag_1
4. set_depth_flag_2
5. set_depth_flag_3
6. set_depth_flag_4
7. build_art_0
8. publish_art_0
9. advance_0 (provision billing-0)
10. advance_1 (configure billing-0)
11. advance_2 (deploy billing-0)
12. advance_3 (health-check billing-0)
Check each precondition holds when called.
Let's simulate initial state:
- flag_0 = off => set_flag_0 allowed.
- After step1 flag_0 true.
Step2 set_depth_flag_0: requires flag_0 true (yes) and depth_flag_0 false (initially false). Good.
Step3 set_depth_flag_1: requires depth_flag_0 true (now true) and depth_flag_1 false. Good.
Step4 set_depth_flag_2: requires depth_flag_1 true (now true) and depth_flag_2 false. Good.
Step5 set_depth_flag_3: requires depth_flag_2 true (now true) and depth_flag_3 false. Good.
Step6 set_depth_flag_4: requires depth_flag_3 true (now true) and depth_flag_4 false. Good.
Now artifacts: Initially absent.
Step7 build_art_0: requires artifact absent (true). After building, artifact becomes built.
Step8 publish_art_0: requires artifact built (true). After publishing, artifact becomes published.
Service billing-0: starts down.
Step9 advance_0 (provision): requires service down (true). Moves to provisioned.
Step10 advance_1 (configure): requires service provisioned (true). Moves to configured.
Step11 advance_2 (deploy): requires service configured (true). Moves to deployed.
Step12 advance_3 (health-check): requires service deployed (true), depth_flag_4 true (we have), art_0 published (true). All satisfied. Moves to healthy.
Thus final condition satisfied.
All used tool IDs as per list: set_flag_0, set_depth_flag_0, set_depth_flag_1, set_depth_flag_2, set_depth_flag_3, set_depth_flag_4, build_art_0, publish_art_0, advance_0, advance_1, advance_2, advance_3.
That's 12 calls within limit.
Need output JSON array with objects: {"tool":"<tool id>", "args":{"<param>":"<entity id>"}}.
Parameters: For set_flag_0 etc., param is flag: flag entity id. Which flag ids?
Given mapping:
- flag_0 (maintenance_window_open) corresponds to flag entity id? They said Flags: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), flag_1 (secrets_synced), depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on), depth_flag_1 (backup_taken), depth_flag_2 (quota_raised), depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open), depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced).
Wait they gave duplicate names? Let's parse:
Entity IDs (use these exact ids in your tool args):
Services: svc_0 (billing-0), svc_1 (cache-1)
Artifacts: art_0 (release-image), art_1 (db-migration)
Flags: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), flag_1 (secrets_synced), depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on), depth_flag_1 (backup_taken), depth_flag_2 (quota_raised), depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open), depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced)
Thus flag_0 is maintenance_window_open, flag_1 is secrets_synced, depth_flag_0 is feature_gate_on, depth_flag_1 is backup_taken, depth_flag_2 is quota_raised, depth_flag_3 is maintenance_window_open (again?), depth_flag_4 is secrets_synced (again?). There seems duplication but okay.
Thus for set_flag_0 tool, which sets flag_0 flag to true. Its param "flag": flag entity id. Should be "flag_0". Similarly set_depth_flag_0 expects flag param: depth_flag_0 entity id. And so on.
Thus our calls:
- set_flag_0: args {"flag":"flag_0"}
- set_depth_flag_0: args {"flag":"depth_flag_0"}
- set_depth_flag_1: args {"flag":"depth_flag_1"}
- set_depth_flag_2: args {"flag":"depth_flag_2"}
- set_depth_flag_3: args {"flag":"depth_flag_3"}
- set_depth_flag_4: args {"flag":"depth_flag_4"}
Build artifact: build_art_0: args {"artifact":"art_0"}.
Publish artifact: publish_art_0: args {"artifact":"art_0"}.
Provision: advance_0: args {"service":"svc_0"}.
Configure: advance_1: args {"service":"svc_0"}.
Deploy: advance_2: args {"service":"svc_0"}.
Health-check: advance_3: args {"service":"svc_0"}.
Make sure all preconditions satisfied.
Double-check dependencies: set_depth_flag_0 requires flag_0 flag first. We set flag_0 before, good.
set_depth_flag_1 requires depth_flag_0 first. We set depth_flag_0 before, good.
set_depth_flag_2 requires depth_flag_1 first. Good.
set_depth_flag_3 requires depth_flag_2 first. Good.
set_depth_flag_4 requires depth_flag_3 first. Good.
Now check if any other hidden preconditions like needing maintenance_window_open flag for something else? Not needed.
Thus final answer: JSON array of 12 objects.
Let's construct.
Realized dims
| dim | value |
|---|---|
| catalog_size | 14.0 |
| chain_length | 8.0 |
| decoy_count | 2.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 0.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 0.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 0.0 |
| irreversibility | 0.0 |
| parallel_goals | 1.0 |
| plan_overhead | 0.0 |
| poison_traps | 0.0 |
| realized_plan_depth | 12.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.0 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |
Latent params
| param | value |
|---|---|
| decoy_tools | 2.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 0.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 0.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 0.0 |
| irreversibility | 0.0 |
| parallel_goals | 1.0 |
| plan_depth | 9.0 |
| poison_traps | 0.0 |
| precondition_chain | 1.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.0 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |