Record 06bb82ed12c44a8d89685b5344033af2
PASSVerdict and provenance first; raw prompt/response/reasoning below, collapsed.
✓PASSanswered "[{"tool":"build_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},{"tool":"publish_art_0","..."
Prompt
You are an operations planner. Below is the current state of a small deployment environment, a goal, and a catalog of tools you may call. Each tool has typed parameters and PRECONDITIONS that must hold at the moment you call it; calling a tool whose preconditions are not met is an error and your plan fails.
CURRENT STATE:
- billing-0 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- notifier-1 is currently down (not yet provisioned).
- The release-image artifact does not exist yet.
- The db-migration artifact does not exist yet.
- The maintenance_window_open flag is off.
- The secrets_synced flag is off.
- The feature_gate_on flag is off.
- The backup_taken flag is off.
- The quota_raised flag is off.
- The maintenance_window_open flag is off.
- The secrets_synced flag is off.
GOAL (all conditions must hold at the end):
- service 'billing-0' must reach at least the 'healthy' state
ENTITY IDS (use these exact ids in your tool args):
Services: svc_0 (billing-0), svc_1 (notifier-1)
Artifacts: art_0 (release-image), art_1 (db-migration)
Flags: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), flag_1 (secrets_synced), depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on), depth_flag_1 (backup_taken), depth_flag_2 (quota_raised), depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open), depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced)
TOOL CATALOG:
- id: publish_art_0 | name: publish_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Publish the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'built' to 'published'). Precondition: the artifact must be 'built'.
- id: advance_2 | name: deploy | params: service: service
Deploy a service, moving it from 'configured' to 'deployed'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'configured'.
- id: decoy_1 | name: warm_cache | params: service: service
Warm the cache for a service (best-effort, no state change). (Has no effect on deployment state.)
- id: advance_3 | name: health-check | params: service: service
Health-check a service, moving it from 'deployed' to 'healthy'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'deployed'. Requires the depth_flag_4 flag to be set. Requires the art_0 artifact to be published.
- id: set_depth_flag_4 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_4 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_3 flag first.
- id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the flag_0 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false.
- id: advance_1 | name: configure | params: service: service
Configure a service, moving it from 'provisioned' to 'configured'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'provisioned'.
- id: set_depth_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_0 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the flag_0 flag first.
- id: set_depth_flag_2 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_2 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_1 flag first.
- id: decoy_0 | name: audit_logs | params: service: service
Audit the log stream for a service (read-only). (Has no effect on deployment state.)
- id: build_art_0 | name: build_artifact | params: artifact: artifact
Build the art_0 artifact (moves it from 'absent' to 'built'). Precondition: the artifact must be 'absent'.
- id: set_depth_flag_3 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_3 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_2 flag first.
- id: advance_0 | name: provision | params: service: service
Provision a service, moving it from 'down' to 'provisioned'. Precondition: the service must currently be 'down'.
- id: set_depth_flag_1 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Set the depth_flag_1 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the depth_flag_0 flag first.
Output ONLY a JSON array of tool calls that, executed in order from the current state, satisfies the goal. Each element must be an object {"tool": "<tool id>", "args": {"<param>": "<entity id>", ...}}. Do not include any prose, explanation, or markdown fences -- just the JSON array.
You may use at most 24 tool calls.
Response
[{"tool":"build_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},{"tool":"publish_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}},{"tool":"set_flag_0","args":{"flag":"flag_0"}},{"tool":"set_depth_flag_0","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_0"}},{"tool":"set_depth_flag_1","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_1"}},{"tool":"set_depth_flag_2","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_2"}},{"tool":"set_depth_flag_3","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_3"}},{"tool":"set_depth_flag_4","args":{"flag":"depth_flag_4"}},{"tool":"advance_0","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},{"tool":"advance_1","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},{"tool":"advance_2","args":{"service":"svc_0"}},{"tool":"advance_3","args":{"service":"svc_0"}}]
Reasoning
Model reasoning
We need to produce a JSON array of tool calls that will achieve the goal: service 'billing-0' must reach at least the 'healthy' state.
We have current state:
- billing-0 is currently down (not yet provisioned). So its state is down.
- notifier-1 is currently down (not yet provisioned). So also down.
- release-image artifact does not exist yet (absent).
- db-migration artifact does not exist yet (absent).
- maintenance_window_open flag is off (presumably false). Actually they list it twice but same.
- secrets_synced flag is off.
- feature_gate_on flag is off.
- backup_taken flag is off.
- quota_raised flag is off.
- maintenance_window_open flag is off (duplicate)
- secrets_synced flag is off (duplicate)
We have entity IDs:
Services: svc_0 (billing-0), svc_1 (notifier-1)
Artifacts: art_0 (release-image), art_1 (db-migration)
Flags: flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), flag_1 (secrets_synced), depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on), depth_flag_1 (backup_taken), depth_flag_2 (quota_raised), depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open), depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced)
Goal: service 'billing-0' must reach at least the 'healthy' state.
To get to healthy, we need to go through steps: provision -> configure -> deploy -> health-check. Also need depth_flag_4 set, and art_0 published.
We also need to set various depth flags maybe to satisfy preconditions.
Let's map the required preconditions.
We need to eventually call health-check (advance_3) on service svc_0. Preconditions: service must be deployed, depth_flag_4 flag must be set, and art_0 artifact must be published.
To get service to deployed, we need to call deploy (advance_2) on service, precondition: service must be configured.
To get service to configured, we need to call configure (advance_1) on service, precondition: service must be provisioned.
To get service provisioned, we need to call provision (advance_0) on service, precondition: service must be down.
Thus we need to sequence: provision -> configure -> deploy -> health-check.
But also need to publish art_0 artifact before health-check. To publish artifact, we need to build it first (build_art_0) which moves from absent to built. Then publish_art_0 moves from built to published. So we need to build then publish.
Also need depth_flag_4 set to true. To set depth_flag_4, precondition: it must currently be false, and requires depth_flag_3 flag first. So we need to set depth_flag_3 first, which requires depth_flag_2, which requires depth_flag_1, which requires depth_flag_0. And each set_flag requires the previous flag to be set first? Actually each set_depth_flag_X has precondition: it must currently be false, and requires the previous flag first. Let's parse:
- set_depth_flag_0 (set_flag_0) name: set_flag, params: flag: flag. Precondition: it must currently be false. Requires the flag_0 flag first. Wait "Requires the flag_0 flag first." That seems ambiguous: maybe it means that flag_0 must be set? Actually flag_0 is maintenance_window_open flag. So to set depth_flag_0, we need flag_0 to be set first? But flag_0 is a flag that can be set via set_flag_0. The precondition for set_flag_0 is that it must currently be false. So you can set it from false to true. The "Requires the flag_0 flag first." maybe means that you need to have flag_0 set? That doesn't make sense. Possibly they meant that setting depth_flag_0 requires flag_0 to be set? But flag_0 is the same as maintenance_window_open flag. Actually flag_0 is maintenance_window_open flag. So to set depth_flag_0, you need flag_0 to be set? But flag_0 is currently off (false). So you could set flag_0 first via set_flag_0? Wait set_flag_0 is "set_flag_0" name: set_flag, params: flag: flag. It sets flag_0 flag to true. Precondition: it must currently be false. So you can set flag_0 from false to true. Then you can set depth_flag_0 (set_depth_flag_0) which also requires flag_0 flag first? Possibly they meant that depth_flag_0 requires flag_0 to be set (i.e., you must have set flag_0 to true before you can set depth_flag_0). That would be a dependency: you must set flag_0 (maintenance_window_open) to true, then you can set depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on) to true. Then set_depth_flag_1 (backup_taken) requires depth_flag_0 first. Then set_depth_flag_2 (quota_raised) requires depth_flag_1 first. Then set_depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open) requires depth_flag_2 first. Then set_depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced) requires depth_flag_3 first.
Thus we have a chain of flags: flag_0 -> depth_flag_0 -> depth_flag_1 -> depth_flag_2 -> depth_flag_3 -> depth_flag_4.
Goal: we need depth_flag_4 to be true for health-check. So we need to set all preceding flags in order.
But do we need any of these flags for anything else? Possibly not, but they are required for depth_flag_4.
Thus we need to set flag_0 (maintenance_window_open) to true via set_flag_0. Then set depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on) to true via set_depth_flag_0. Then set depth_flag_1 (backup_taken) to true via set_depth_flag_1. Then set depth_flag_2 (quota_raised) to true via set_depth_flag_2. Then set depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open) to true via set_depth_flag_3. Then set depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced) to true via set_depth_flag_4.
But note that there is also a flag_1 (secrets_synced) which is separate? Actually flag_1 is secrets_synced flag. But depth_flag_4 is also secrets_synced? They have both flag_1 and depth_flag_4 named secrets_synced. Possibly flag_1 is the base flag, and depth_flag_4 is a deeper flag that also references secrets_synced. The precondition for set_depth_flag_4 says "Requires the depth_flag_3 flag first." So we need to set depth_flag_3 before depth_flag_4. depth_flag_3 is maintenance_window_open (same name as flag_0). So we need to set depth_flag_3 after depth_flag_2, etc.
Thus we need to set a chain of flags.
But do we need to set flag_1 (secrets_synced) at all? Not necessarily, but maybe it's required for something else? The goal only requires health-check, which requires depth_flag_4. So we need to set depth_flag_4, which requires depth_flag_3, which requires depth_flag_2, which requires depth_flag_1, which requires depth_flag_0, which requires flag_0. So we need to set flag_0, then depth_flag_0, then depth_flag_1, then depth_flag_2, then depth_flag_3, then depth_flag_4.
But note that set_depth_flag_0 requires flag_0 flag first. That means we must have set flag_0 to true before we can set depth_flag_0. So we need to call set_flag_0 (set_flag_0) to set flag_0 to true. Then we can call set_depth_flag_0 to set depth_flag_0 to true.
Now, do we need to set any other flags? Possibly not.
Now, we also need to build and publish artifact art_0. That requires it to be absent initially, which it is. So we can build_art_0 (build_artifact) with artifact: art_0. Then publish_art_0 (publish_artifact) with artifact: art_0.
Now, we need to provision service svc_0 (billing-0). It is down. So we can call advance_0 (provision) with service: svc_0.
After provisioned, we can configure it: advance_1 (configure) with service: svc_0.
Then deploy: advance_2 (deploy) with service: svc_0.
Now service is deployed. Then we need to health-check: advance_3 (health-check) with service: svc_0. Preconditions: service must be deployed (which we have), depth_flag_4 must be set (we will set it), and art_0 artifact must be published (we will publish it). So after we have set depth_flag_4 and published art_0, we can health-check.
Thus the plan is:
1. build_art_0 (artifact: art_0)
2. publish_art_0 (artifact: art_0)
3. set_flag_0 (flag: flag_0) to set maintenance_window_open flag to true.
4. set_depth_flag_0 (flag: depth_flag_0) to set feature_gate_on to true.
5. set_depth_flag_1 (flag: depth_flag_1) to set backup_taken to true.
6. set_depth_flag_2 (flag: depth_flag_2) to set quota_raised to true.
7. set_depth_flag_3 (flag: depth_flag_3) to set maintenance_window_open (again?) to true.
8. set_depth_flag_4 (flag: depth_flag_4) to set secrets_synced to true.
9. advance_0 (provision) service: svc_0
10. advance_1 (configure) service: svc_0
11. advance_2 (deploy) service: svc_0
12. advance_3 (health-check) service: svc_0
We need to ensure each tool's precondition is satisfied at the moment we call it.
Let's verify each step's precondition:
- build_art_0: precondition: artifact must be absent. It is absent. So ok.
- publish_art_0: precondition: artifact must be built. After build_art_0, it becomes built. So ok.
- set_flag_0 (set_flag_0): precondition: flag must be false. Initially it's off (false). So ok. Also requires flag_0 flag first? Actually the description: "Requires the flag_0 flag first." Might be a mistake; but maybe they meant that you need to have flag_0 defined? But it's the same flag. Probably they meant you need to have flag_0 set? That would be circular. But likely they meant you need to have flag_0 defined (which it is). So we can set it.
- set_depth_flag_0 (set_depth_flag_0): precondition: it must currently be false. Initially it's false. Requires the flag_0 flag first. That likely means flag_0 must be set to true first. So after step 3, flag_0 is true, so we can set depth_flag_0.
- set_depth_flag_1 (set_depth_flag_1): precondition: it must be false, requires depth_flag_0 first. After step 4, depth_flag_0 is true, so ok.
- set_depth_flag_2 (set_depth_flag_2): precondition: it must be false, requires depth_flag_1 first. After step 5, depth_flag_1 is true, so ok.
- set_depth_flag_3 (set_depth_flag_3): precondition: it must be false, requires depth_flag_2 first. After step 6, depth_flag_2 is true, so ok.
- set_depth_flag_4 (set_depth_flag_4): precondition: it must be false, requires depth_flag_3 first. After step 7, depth_flag_3 is true, so ok.
Now after these flag settings, depth_flag_4 is true.
Now provision service svc_0: advance_0 (provision) precondition: service must be down. It is down. So ok.
After provision, service becomes provisioned.
Then configure: advance_1 (configure) precondition: service must be provisioned. After provision, it is provisioned. So ok.
Then deploy: advance_2 (deploy) precondition: service must be configured. After configure, it is configured. So ok.
Then health-check: advance_3 (health-check) precondition: service must be deployed, depth_flag_4 must be set, and art_0 must be published. After steps 1-8, depth_flag_4 is true, art_0 is published. After steps 9-11, service is deployed. So health-check can be called.
Thus the sequence of 12 tool calls should satisfy.
But we need to output only a JSON array of tool calls, each with "tool": "<tool id>", "args": {...}. No extra text.
We must use exact tool IDs from catalog:
- build_art_0 (id: build_art_0) name: build_artifact, params: artifact: artifact
- publish_art_0 (id: publish_art_0) name: publish_artifact, params: artifact: artifact
- set_depth_flag_0 (id: set_depth_flag_0) name: set_flag, params: flag: flag
- set_depth_flag_1 (id: set_depth_flag_1) name: set_flag, params: flag: flag
- set_depth_flag_2 (id: set_depth_flag_2) name: set_flag, params: flag: flag
- set_depth_flag_3 (id: set_depth_flag_3) name: set_flag, params: flag: flag
- set_depth_flag_4 (id: set_depth_flag_4) name: set_flag, params: flag: flag
- advance_0 (id: advance_0) name: provision, params: service: service
- advance_1 (id: advance_1) name: configure, params: service: service
- advance_2 (id: advance_2) name: deploy, params: service: service
- advance_3 (id: advance_3) name: health-check, params: service: service
We also have set_flag_0 (id: set_flag_0) but that's same as set_depth_flag_0? Actually set_flag_0 is "set_flag_0" name: set_flag, params: flag: flag. That sets flag_0. So we should use id: set_flag_0 for setting flag_0. But the catalog lists both set_depth_flag_0 and set_flag_0. Let's parse:
- id: set_depth_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
- id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Wait they have both set_depth_flag_0 and set_flag_0. Actually they listed:
- id: set_depth_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
- id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
But earlier they also listed:
- id: set_depth_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
- id: set_depth_flag_1 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
- id: set_depth_flag_2 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
- id: set_depth_flag_3 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
- id: set_depth_flag_4 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
But also they listed:
- id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
Actually the catalog includes:
- id: set_depth_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
- id: set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag
But they also have "set_depth_flag_0" and "set_flag_0". Possibly a mistake: set_depth_flag_0 is the tool to set depth_flag_0, while set_flag_0 is the tool to set flag_0. But both have same name "set_flag"? The difference is the id. So we need to use the correct id for each flag.
Thus:
- To set flag_0 (maintenance_window_open), we should use id: set_flag_0 (since that sets flag_0). The description: "set_flag_0 | name: set_flag | params: flag: flag". Precondition: it must currently be false. So we can call set_flag_0 with flag: flag_0.
- To set depth_flag_0 (feature_gate_on), we should use id: set_depth_flag_0, with flag: depth_flag_0.
- To set depth_flag_1 (backup_taken), use id: set_depth_flag_1, with flag: depth_flag_1.
- To set depth_flag_2 (quota_raised), use id: set_depth_flag_2, with flag: depth_flag_2.
- To set depth_flag_3 (maintenance_window_open), use id: set_depth_flag_3, with flag: depth_flag_3.
- To set depth_flag_4 (secrets_synced), use id: set_depth_flag_4, with flag: depth_flag_4.
Thus we need to use the appropriate ids.
Now we need to produce JSON array of tool calls in order.
Let's list them with correct ids and args.
1. build_art_0 with artifact: art_0
2. publish_art_0 with artifact: art_0
3. set_flag_0 with flag: flag_0
4. set_depth_flag_0 with flag: depth_flag_0
5. set_depth_flag_1 with flag: depth_flag_1
6. set_depth_flag_2 with flag: depth_flag_2
7. set_depth_flag_3 with flag: depth_flag_3
8. set_depth_flag_4 with flag: depth_flag_4
9. advance_0 with service: svc_0
10. advance_1 with service: svc_0
11. advance_2 with service: svc_0
12. advance_3 with service: svc_0
Check each precondition:
- build_art_0: artifact must be absent. It is absent. OK.
- publish_art_0: artifact must be built. After build, it is built. OK.
- set_flag_0: flag must be false. flag_0 is off initially. OK. No other precondition.
- set_depth_flag_0: must be false, requires flag_0 flag first. After step 3, flag_0 is true, so OK.
- set_depth_flag_1: must be false, requires depth_flag_0 first. After step 4, depth_flag_0 is true, so OK.
- set_depth_flag_2: must be false, requires depth_flag_1 first. After step 5, depth_flag_1 is true, so OK.
- set_depth_flag_3: must be false, requires depth_flag_2 first. After step 6, depth_flag_2 is true, so OK.
- set_depth_flag_4: must be false, requires depth_flag_3 first. After step 7, depth_flag_3 is true, so OK.
- advance_0: service must be down. svc_0 is down. OK.
- advance_1: service must be provisioned. After advance_0, it becomes provisioned. OK.
- advance_2: service must be configured. After advance_1, it becomes configured. OK.
- advance_3: service must be deployed, depth_flag_4 must be set, and art_0 must be published. After steps 1-8, depth_flag_4 is true and art_0 is published. After step 11, service is deployed. So OK.
Thus the sequence works.
Now we need to output JSON array of objects with "tool" and "args". The args should be key-value pairs with entity ids.
For build_art_0: args: {"artifact": "art_0"}
For publish_art_0: args: {"artifact": "art_0"}
For set_flag_0: args: {"flag": "flag_0"}
For set_depth_flag_0: args: {"flag": "depth_flag_0"}
For set_depth_flag_1: args: {"flag": "depth_flag_1"}
For set_depth_flag_2: args: {"flag": "depth_flag_2"}
For set_depth_flag_3: args: {"flag": "depth_flag_3"}
For set_depth_flag_4: args: {"flag": "depth_flag_4"}
For advance_0: args: {"service": "svc_0"}
For advance_1: args: {"service": "svc_0"}
For advance_2: args: {"service": "svc_0"}
For advance_3: args: {"service": "svc_0"}
Now ensure JSON array format: [{"tool":"build_art_0","args":{"artifact":"art_0"}}, ...]
No extra text, no markdown.
We must output only the JSON array.
Check that we are within 24 calls: we have 12 calls, fine.
Now produce final answer.
Realized dims
| dim | value |
|---|---|
| catalog_size | 14.0 |
| chain_length | 8.0 |
| decoy_count | 2.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 0.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 0.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 0.0 |
| irreversibility | 0.0 |
| parallel_goals | 1.0 |
| plan_overhead | 0.0 |
| poison_traps | 0.0 |
| realized_plan_depth | 12.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.0 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |
Latent params
| param | value |
|---|---|
| decoy_tools | 2.0 |
| dishonest_decoys_on | 0.0 |
| id_collisions_on | 0.0 |
| implicit_preconditions_on | 0.0 |
| irreversibility | 0.0 |
| parallel_goals | 1.0 |
| plan_depth | 9.0 |
| poison_traps | 0.0 |
| precondition_chain | 1.0 |
| state_obscurity | 0.0 |
| zero_slack_on | 0.0 |